| Emory University | GA | United Methodist | |
| Southern Methodist University | TX | United Methodist | |
| American University | DC | United Methodist | |
| Duke University | NC | United Methodist | |
| High Point University | NC | United Methodist | |
| Clark Atlanta University | GA | United Methodist | |
| University of Indianapolis | IN | United Methodist | |
| Bethune-Cookman University | FL | United Methodist | |
| Florida Southern College | FL | United Methodist | |
| Ohio Northern University | OH | United Methodist | |
| North Central College | IL | United Methodist | |
| Otterbein University | OH | United Methodist | |
| Shenandoah University | VA | United Methodist | |
| Wofford College | SC | United Methodist | |
| Hamline University | MN | United Methodist | |
| Seattle Pacific University | WA | Free Methodist | |
| McKendree University | IL | United Methodist | |
| Texas Wesleyan University | TX | United Methodist | |
| Claflin University | SC | United Methodist | |
| Lebanon Valley College | PA | United Methodist | |
| Randolph-Macon College | VA | United Methodist | |
| Adrian College | MI | United Methodist | |
| Lindsey Wilson College | KY | United Methodist | |
| University of Evansville | IN | United Methodist | |
| Drew University | NJ | United Methodist | |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | OH | United Methodist | |
| Oklahoma City University | OK | United Methodist | |
| Nebraska Wesleyan University | NE | United Methodist | |
| Methodist University | NC | United Methodist | |
| Southwestern University | TX | United Methodist | |
| Columbia College | SC | United Methodist | |
| Virginia Wesleyan University | VA | United Methodist | |
| Simpson College | IA | United Methodist | |
| Albright College | PA | United Methodist | |
| North Carolina Wesleyan University | NC | United Methodist | |
| McMurry University | TX | United Methodist | |
| Morningside University | IA | United Methodist | |
| Allegheny College | PA | United Methodist | |
| Miles College | AL | Christian Methodist Episcopal | |
| Roberts Wesleyan University | NY | Free Methodist | |
| Baker University | KS | United Methodist | |
| Hendrix College | AR | United Methodist | |
| Edward Waters University | FL | African Methodist Episcopal | |
| Cornell College | IA | United Methodist | |
| Emory & Henry University | VA | United Methodist | |
| Reinhardt University | GA | United Methodist | |
| Dillard University | LA | United Methodist | |
| Central Methodist University-College of Liberal Arts and Sciences | MO | United Methodist | |
| Spring Arbor University | MI | Free Methodist | |
| Lycoming College | PA | United Methodist | |
| Kansas Wesleyan University | KS | United Methodist | |
| Greenville University | IL | Free Methodist | |
| West Virginia Wesleyan College | WV | United Methodist | |
| Livingstone College | NC | African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church | |
| Southwestern College | KS | United Methodist | |
| Centenary University | NJ | United Methodist | |
| Huntingdon College | AL | United Methodist | |
| Tennessee Wesleyan University | TN | United Methodist | |
| Kentucky Wesleyan College | KY | United Methodist | |
| Wilberforce University | OH | African Methodist Episcopal | |
| Brevard College | NC | United Methodist | |
| Young Harris College | GA | United Methodist | |
| Philander Smith University | AR | United Methodist | |
| Union Commonwealth University | KY | United Methodist | |
| Lane College | TN | Christian Methodist Episcopal | |
| Wiley University | TX | United Methodist | |
| Greensboro College | NC | United Methodist | |
| Ferrum College | VA | United Methodist | |
| Centenary College of Louisiana | LA | United Methodist | |
| Dakota Wesleyan University | SD | United Methodist | |
| Pfeiffer University | NC | United Methodist | |
| LaGrange College | GA | United Methodist | |
| Paul Quinn College | TX | African Methodist Episcopal | |
| Texas College | TX | Christian Methodist Episcopal | |
| Allen University | SC | African Methodist Episcopal | |
| Millsaps College | MS | United Methodist | |
| Rust College | MS | United Methodist | |
| Alaska Pacific University | AK | United Methodist | |
| Wesleyan College | GA | United Methodist | |
| Paine College | GA | United Methodist | |
| Central Christian College of Kansas | KS | Free Methodist | |
| Bennett College | NC | United Methodist | |